Understand Your Rights. Solve Your Legal Problems
A family trip aboard the Carnival Horizon has spiraled into a criminal investigation after the sudden death of 18-year-old Anna Kepner, a straight-A student and cheerleader from Titusville, Florida.
Kepner was found unresponsive on the ship earlier this month, and a new court filing now reveals that one of her juvenile step-siblings may face charges connected to her death.
The revelation surfaced in a Miami-Dade family court proceeding on Monday, where Kepner’s stepmother asked to delay a custody hearing.
She told the court she had been informed through her lawyers and discussions with federal investigators that one of her minor children is now part of a potential criminal case tied to Anna’s death.
The FBI, which took over the investigation immediately after the incident, has not released details about what happened on board or what evidence agents are reviewing.
The Miami-Dade medical examiner has not determined Anna’s cause or manner of death. The cruise ship returned to Miami the same day Anna died.
The Carnival Horizon was sailing its regular Miami-to-Caribbean route when Anna was reported dead on Nov. 8.
Passengers recalled an abrupt shift in the ship’s schedule as crew members notified authorities, triggering federal jurisdiction—standard protocol when a death occurs at sea involving a U.S. citizen.
Because Anna died in international waters and the ship docked in Florida, the case was automatically routed to the FBI’s Miami field office, which oversees major incidents on U.S.-based cruise lines.
The dramatic shift came not from investigators but from a procedural motion in family court, where Anna’s stepmother explained she could not participate in a scheduled hearing.
Her reasoning: testimony in that custody case could influence or compromise a criminal investigation involving one of her children.
Friends and relatives described Anna as a high-achieving teenager with a bright future, someone who brought energy and humor to every room.
Her death stunned her community in Titusville, where her high school cheer squad and classmates held memorial gatherings.
For a family already grieving, the possibility that another child in the household could now be pulled into a federal case has compounded the emotional fallout.
When a death occurs aboard a cruise ship that departs from or returns to a U.S. port, the investigation falls under federal authority.
If a minor is connected to any part of that inquiry, the process becomes more complex and is handled under strict privacy rules.
The FBI leads these cases because serious incidents on cruise ships sailing from U.S. ports fall under federal jurisdiction.
Once the ship docks, agents work with medical examiners to review evidence, gather witness accounts, and determine whether a crime may have occurred.
If investigators find evidence pointing to possible wrongdoing by someone under 18, the case moves into the federal juvenile system.
This system is separate from adult criminal court and focuses on rehabilitation rather than punishment.
All proceedings are sealed to protect the minor’s identity, and prosecutors must meet specific federal standards to show criminal intent. Outcomes can range from supervised programs to secure juvenile custody in more serious circumstances.
A parent’s statements in any legal proceeding can be reviewed by investigators, which is why testimony in a separate family case may be postponed. The concern is that certain statements could unintentionally affect the juvenile’s legal position.
Next steps typically depend on the medical examiner’s findings, the evidence gathered by the FBI, and whether federal prosecutors believe the legal threshold for charges is met.
Until those decisions are made, all information involving the juvenile remains confidential under federal law.
Carnival Cruise Line has said only that it is cooperating fully with federal investigators and supporting Kepner’s family. Large cruise lines routinely provide access to surveillance footage, security logs, passenger lists, and digital records when an incident occurs on board.
The Horizon completed its itinerary after returning to Miami, but the section of the ship connected to the investigation remained closed while federal agents worked through it.
While authorities have not confirmed the circumstances of Anna’s death, the ongoing involvement of family members suggests the case is far from routine.
